Waymo Self-Driving Cars: Between Innovation and Societal Challenges

The Phenomenon of Frequent Stops and Residents' Concerns

A Familiar Sight: In West Los Angeles, Waymo self-driving cars have become a familiar sight, stopping and waiting in front of residential homes. This phenomenon sparks residents' curiosity and questions, especially as these stops recur in the same locations day after day, sometimes for minutes and sometimes for hours. This phenomenon represents the latest challenge facing cities embracing technological transportation innovations, reminiscent of the emergence of services like Uber and Bird scooters in the past, which also caused some friction with local communities.

Growing Ambiguity: The ambiguity surrounding these interactions is heightened by the nature of artificial intelligence. Driverless cars appear confused and stop randomly, while mandatory backup sounds are a nuisance to residents. Questions also arise about these cars' adherence to local traffic laws. Some residents are bothered by cars parking in their neighborhoods, and others express concern about the continuously operating cameras and sensors. But the vast majority simply want to understand why their homes or neighborhoods are becoming unofficial waiting areas for Waymo cars.

“Image of a businessman pointing to a whiteboard” — Source: Pixabay. License: CC0.

Understanding Waymo's Parking Behavior

A Global Phenomenon: This phenomenon is not limited to one family; other residents in Los Angeles, Phoenix, and Scottsdale have observed the same repeated parking behavior of Waymo cars in their areas. The company indicates that street parking may be a normal part of Waymo vehicles' daily routine. In addition to the parking depots spread across Los Angeles, where these cars are charged and cleaned, Waymo explains that its cars also park outside these designated areas when not in use.

Waymo's Research Efforts: Vishay Nihalani, Waymo's Product Management Director, explains that their vehicles search for suitable parking spots to wait for short periods between trips, whether in dedicated Waymo parking facilities or in available on-street parking spaces. Waymo is currently participating in an upcoming research study in collaboration with the University of California, Berkeley, and the University of California, Irvine, to analyze on-street parking behavior and its impact on passenger waiting times and traffic congestion. Waymo supports this research by providing researchers with aggregated and simulated data to help deeply understand this phenomenon.

Wikimedia Commons

Parking Mechanisms and Influencing Factors

Fundamental Difference: The street parking behavior of Waymo cars differs from that of traditional taxis or other ride-hailing vehicles. If a Waymo car is not at a depot, or doesn't need to go there for charging or maintenance, it won't necessarily seek immediate rides like an Uber driver. In the absence of a large number of ride requests, Waymo may choose to park to conserve energy and avoid contributing to traffic, while ensuring continued service coverage in less congested areas.

Multiple Factors: Factors influencing Waymo's choices for parking locations include local parking regulations, the number of vehicles already parked in a specific area, and the expected duration of its stop. If other Waymo vehicles are already serving the neighborhood, the individual car is likely to move on. If it tends to wait for long periods in a particular spot, this may indicate low demand in that area, which could influence Waymo's future parking decisions for that location.

Mystery of Choice: While Waymo provides an overview of its parking options, it does not address the specificity of the places its vehicles choose to stop – such as repeatedly stopping in front of the same residential home or building. Waymo acknowledges this phenomenon of frequent stops but indicates that the AI in the cars makes many dynamic decisions in driving and parking, considering safety, accessibility, and congestion, to the extent that it cannot pinpoint why a Waymo car chooses a particular spot to stop or park.

Expert Opinion: Phil Koopman, a professor at Carnegie Mellon University and an expert in autonomous vehicles, points out that the computer does the same thing the same way every time, which is not surprising. Koopman believes that Waymo uses machine learning to guide its curbside parking decisions, meaning engineers provide the cars with data that allows them to make their own decisions based on that data, rather than providing specific instructions via a human-written algorithm.

Proposed Solutions: Waymo confirms that it is technically possible to mark a location as a no-parking zone for Waymo vehicles, and the company has done so in response to neighbor complaints. In recent months, Waymo has seen a significant increase in usage, meaning opportunities for robotaxis to stop and rest may be less frequent as Waymo's fleet of 500 cars in Los Angeles begins to meet the city's resident demand.

Waymo Challenges: Self-Driving Car Noise and Resident Concerns

Santa Monica Noise: Waymo self-driving cars have faced increasing complaints from residents in various areas, particularly regarding noise from these vehicles. In Santa Monica, residents expressed their annoyance with the noise from Waymo charging stations and car stops, noting that disruptive noises, such as honking sounds from cars when backing up or stopping, have become a daily nuisance. This has prompted some residents to publicly protest, even attempting to obstruct driverless taxis in Santa Monica to express their anger. You can find out more about Waymo's noise issues, and read details about Waymo car noise complaints in Santa Monica.

Nightly Honking Problem in San Francisco: In a related context, reports from August 2024 in San Francisco showed that Waymo cars were repeatedly honking at night, disturbing residents and keeping them awake. Waymo confirmed on August 15, 2024, that it had released an update to address the nightly honking problem of its self-driving cars in San Francisco, in a move to calm local concerns and improve residents' living experience. For more on Waymo's honking sounds in the parking lot, and how Waymo fixed the nightly honking problem, you can follow these sources.